Friday, June 05, 2009

Option key (updated)

I love Macintosh computers, but they have a few little brain-dead things that they seem to insist on. Like the short cable for the mouse. Or the option-key.
I'll bet most Mac users at one point runs into this one: some instructions say "press the option key and..." and they look all over the keyboard, finding no option key.

Well, the "option key" is the one helpfully labelled "alt". Like I said, brain-dead.
And it has an odd little symbol on it. I guess it's meant to symbolize a track diverging, thus giving "options" (?).


By the way, the "command" key is also usually not labeled well. It's the one with the apple. Verrrrry logical. The other strange symbol means "remarkable feature" when seen on road signs. Apple adopted it to mean "command" and forgot to tell the rest of the world.


Update: it seems Bron is right when he says his keyboard from a 24-inch iMac does it right:

Funny thing is that mine, here, is also from a 24-inch iMac:
I guess you just never knows what Apple does from day to day.
Or maybe it's a UK/Eu/US difference? Mine is a UK one.

Update: David Pogue tells me: "It is indeed a US/UK thing."

16 comments:

Anonymous said...

You think that's bad...on my keyboard, the alt and command keys are SWITCHED. I can't remember why it got set up that way, but I'm afraid to switch it back, because I'm so used to it the way it is. But as soon as I get back on a regular Mac keyboard I'm not going to know how to do anything without thinking about it.

Mike

Bronislaus Janulis / Framewright said...

Eolake,

Look at the new apple keyboards; the three keys are: control, option, command. Infinite loop, but no munched apple.

Mines about a year old.

Bron

Anonymous said...

"I guess it's meant to symbolize a track diverging, thus giving "options" (?)"

This symbol, originating on the Apple Lisa, represented the pull-out plastic card situated under the Lisa keyboard.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Option_key

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Command_key

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Control_key

I suppose when the total sum of human knowledge is available from Wikipedia, knowledge and experience will be even less well regarded than they are now.

Eolake Stobblehouse said...

Bron, do the keys *say* "option" and "command"? (And is it an alu keyboard?)

If they do, that's finally a big step forward. I have some pretty new Apple keyboards here, and none of them do.

---
Mike, probably they got switched because the Mac was used at one time with a PC keyboard.

Eolake Stobblehouse said...

... I looked up my un-used alu keyboard... the apple is replaced by "cmd", which is progress.

Bronislaus Janulis / Framewright said...

Eolake,

I just sent an e-mail to whatever address of yours I have, service.

Bron

M. Pipolo said...

My 2005 iBook had "control-alt- *loopy symbol*" IIRC. I now have an original 2006 MacBook and a late-2007 MacBook. The 2006 has "control-option- *loopy symbol*" and the 2007 has "control-option-command".

So... it seems Apple is slowly evolving to more sensical labeling. :)

Royce said...

That's why the PC systems have always been at the forefront of computing. The PC has been king for many years. The SGI machines are king in the digital film/motion picture realm, and then there's the McApple, never able to decide what to do exactly. The Apple disease is all about making money and not about empowering people who use the product. Apple will go GM soon.

Bruce Oksol said...

....Royce, said cheekily.

AAPL's market cap is 128 billion and only has about 4% penetration in the computer business; while MSFT has $194 billion market cap and practically controls the PC world.

It is exactly these idiosyncrasies of Apple that makes it so iconic.

And, if I remember correctly, manuals for Apples were either very thin or non-existent, compared to novels (often fiction) on how to operate a PC.

There's just something iconic and aesthetic about the Apple keyboard.

Note that no one talks about the PC keyboard.

Alex said...

Hmm, must be a modern thing, I remember the old apple keyboards to be very intuitive. All the onscreen prompts used the symbols to show which key to use.

Infinite Loop key, I always saw it as an augmented hash. Still, "One Infinite Loop" was the address of Apple back in the 90's (where are they now).

As for PC keyboards. You could speak volumes about them. I saw a concave QWERTY keypad at the hospital the other day. I just expected it to be Dvorak. Still, PC's are so bad no one talks about them.

Royce said...

Oh yeah - PCs are bad - that's why there's so many millions of them in use. And the reason the keyboards aren't being talked about is the same exact reason nobody talks about a wrench. They're tools, and they work. If Apple could come up with a keyboard that could randomly change the position of it's keys, they would - just for the publicity.

Anonymous said...

my macbookpro keyboard has got a fourth key, to the left of the three pictured by you. it says "fn" on it. i have no idea what it is good for.

Eolake Stobblehouse said...

That changes the function of the F keys (F1 through F13).

Alex said...

Doesn't FN also sometimes give access to the faux numeric pad on "UIO,JKL,M"? Or am I thinking of Num Lock?

FN can also modify arrow keys, my brightness on one machine is implemented that way.

Also there were millions of Ford Escorts, Minis, Citroen 2CV, Lada (also FSO, Polski FIAT, Yugo et al) and VW Beetles in use. Does that make them good, or good enough?

Eolake Stobblehouse said...

David Pogue tells me: "It is indeed a US/UK thing."

Alex said...

But WE are the UK?

I still believe that the Acorn far outgunned the Apple and the PC at the time (1992-4). They were using Arm processors while Macs were still 68K and PC's still 386's. Can't say that wasn't forward looking.